Shingle warranty comparison chart
Every major brand sells its flagship architectural shingle with a lifetime limited warranty, but the part that pays in full, the non-prorated period, is 10 years for most of them and 20 years for Malarkey Legacy. Coverage of up to 50 years non-prorated exists only in system warranties sold through certified contractors. The chart compares one flagship line per brand, for a single-family home owned by an individual.
7 of 7 brands shown. Select a column heading to sort.
| Standard limited warranty | Enhanced / system tiers | Transferability | Certified installer required? | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atlas Pinnacle Pristine | Lifetime limited source | 10 years (Premium Protection) (unconfirmed) | Signature Select Roofing System (adds tear-off and disposal) source | 15 years source | 130 mph source | Lifetime (Scotchgard), with Atlas Pro-Cut Hip & Ridge featuring Scotchgard source | Base: limited coverage to 2nd owner; Signature Select: fully transferable source | Signature Select must be registered; see Atlas for contractor rules (unconfirmed) |
| CertainTeed Landmark | Lifetime limited source | 10 years (SureStart) source | SureStart PLUS 3-Star, 4-Star, 5-Star (5-Star adds workmanship) source | 50 years source | 110 mph; 130 mph upgrade available source | 15 years; 25–30 with CertainTeed AR hip and ridge source | SureStart PLUS: fully transferable 15 yrs (3-Star) or 20 yrs (4/5-Star); base: transferee limited to 50 yrs source | No for base; credentialed contractor for SureStart PLUS; SELECT ShingleMaster for 5-Star source |
| GAF Timberline HDZ | Lifetime limited source | 10 years (Smart Choice) source | System Plus, Silver Pledge, Golden Pledge (25 yrs workmanship) source | 50 years source | 110 mph; 130 mph with special installation; WindProven: no max (LayerLock + GAF accessories) source | 25 years (StainGuard Plus), 10 non-prorated source | Free transfer; lifetime carries to 2nd owner only if transferred in the Smart Choice period source | No for base; GAF Certified for System Plus; Master Elite for Golden Pledge source |
| IKO Cambridge | Limited lifetime source | 10 years (Iron Clad, U.S.) source | ROOFPRO Extended Iron Clad Protection source | 15 years source | 110 mph; 130 mph high-wind upgrade source | Algae-resistant; term per IKO warranty (unconfirmed) | Transferee gets the lesser of 10 years from install or the remaining term source | No for base; ROOFPRO Select or Craftsman Premier for extended source |
| Malarkey Legacy | Limited lifetime source | 20 years (Right Start) source | Certified Pro; Certified Premium (adds workmanship) source | 50 years source | 110 mph; 130 mph enhanced source | Limited lifetime (Scotchgard) source | See Malarkey warranty transfer section (unconfirmed) | No for base; Certified Pro or Premium contractor + 3 Malarkey accessories for enhanced source |
| Owens Corning Duration | Limited lifetime source | 10 years (TRU PROtection) source | System, Preferred, Platinum Protection (lifetime workmanship, reduced after 25 yrs) source | 50 years source | 130 mph; up to 160 mph from Aug 1, 2026 with OC system and starter source | 10 years; 25 with an OC hip and ridge product source | One transfer to the second owner; see warranty for the window (unconfirmed) | No for base; Preferred contractor for Preferred; Platinum Preferred for Platinum source |
| TAMKO Heritage | Limited lifetime source | 10 years (Full Start) source | Edge program: HeritageShield, ProShield, MasterShield source | 30 years source | 110 mph; 130 mph high-wind application (15 years) source | 10-year Algae Cleaning Limited Warranty source | One transfer during the first 5 years source | No for base; TAMKO Pro or MasterCraft Pro for Edge warranties source |
Each cell links to the manufacturer document it comes from. Cells marked unconfirmed are terms we could not confirm in a manufacturer document; check the current warranty for those. Terms change and vary by product, so ask the contractor for the warranty that applies to the exact shingle and date of your install.
The short answer
The brand matters less than the tier. A 10-year non-prorated period with the base warranty is normal; a 15- to 50-year period comes from a system warranty that your contractor has to be certified to register. Ask which tier they will register, in writing.
How to read a shingle warranty
- Limited lifetime means as long as the original owner owns a single-family home. GAF defines it that way in its shingle and accessory limited warranty; other building types get a fixed term.
- Non-prorated period is the window when a confirmed defect is covered in full. GAF calls it Smart Choice, Owens Corning TRU PROtection, CertainTeed SureStart, IKO Iron Clad, Atlas Premium Protection, Malarkey Right Start and TAMKO Full Start.
- Prorated coverage follows. TAMKO, for example, prorates the replacement shingles each year until year 40, after which it pays 20% of their reasonable cost, according to TAMKO's lifetime warranty announcement.
- Wind and algae coverage runs separately, with its own term. Owens Corning states that the TRU PROtection period does not apply to wind or algae coverage.
System warranties and certified installers
The long non-prorated numbers in the chart all come from system warranties. They require the brand's own accessories (starter, hip and ridge, underlayment and more) and a contractor in the brand's program:
- GAF: System Plus, Silver Pledge and Golden Pledge; the Golden Pledge needs a GAF Master Elite contractor. See GAF's warranty comparison chart.
- Owens Corning: System, Preferred and Platinum Protection; Platinum needs a Platinum Preferred contractor (Owens Corning warranties).
- CertainTeed: SureStart PLUS 3-Star, 4-Star and 5-Star with an Integrity Roof System; 5-Star needs a SELECT ShingleMaster (CertainTeed credentialing).
- IKO: ROOFPRO Extended Iron Clad Protection, 15 years on Cambridge in the U.S. (IKO ROOFPRO application).
- Atlas: Signature Select Roofing System, which adds tear-off and disposal coverage (Atlas homeowner guide).
- Malarkey: Certified Pro and Certified Premium, for Malarkey shingles plus three Malarkey accessories (Malarkey warranty chart).
- TAMKO: HeritageShield, ProShield and MasterShield under the Edge program, with 15-, 20- and 30-year Full Start periods (TAMKO Edge).
Our GAF vs Owens Corning comparison walks through those two ladders in more detail.
What voids a shingle warranty
- Installation outside the instructions. TAMKO covers shingles installed "in strict accordance with the Application Instructions"; nail count and placement also decide wind ratings at GAF, IKO and TAMKO.
- Mixing accessories. Owens Corning drops its algae warranty from 25 to 10 years without its own ridge product. CertainTeed needs its AR hip and ridge for 25- or 30-year algae coverage, and Atlas its Pro-Cut Hip & Ridge for lifetime algae coverage.
- Not registering. Enhanced warranties exist only once the contractor registers them; a contractor who isn't in the program can't.
- Missing the transfer window. TAMKO requires the transfer to happen with the sale and written notice within 30 days; other brands set their own windows.
- Excluded damage. TAMKO's warranty, for example, excludes hail, ice damming, and wind beyond the Limited Wind Warranty. Storm damage is an insurance claim, not a warranty claim; see roof insurance: ACV vs RCV.
Questions to ask your roofer about the warranty
- Which warranty tier will you register, and can I see the sample document?
- Are you certified at the level that tier requires? Can I check it on the manufacturer's site?
- Which accessories are you using, and are they all the shingle maker's?
- Who covers workmanship, for how long, and is it you or the manufacturer?
- What do I need to do to transfer the warranty if I sell?
Use our roofing contractor hiring checklist and roofing estimate red flags to check the rest of the bid, and the asphalt shingle roof cost calculator for the price. For any other material, or to see how tear-off and pitch move the total, use the roof replacement cost calculator. More guides are in our contractor guides.
Sources
Manufacturer warranty documents linked in the chart and above, checked November 2026: GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, IKO, Atlas, Malarkey and TAMKO. Some links point to copies of a manufacturer's own warranty document hosted by a distributor. This chart summarizes; the signed warranty document governs.
Frequently asked questions
Which shingle brand has the best warranty?
On the standard warranty, Malarkey Legacy has the longest non-prorated period in our chart at 20 years; GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, IKO, Atlas and TAMKO start at 10. With a certified contractor, GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed and Malarkey offer system warranties with up to 50 years non-prorated. The best warranty is the one your contractor can actually register.
What does non-prorated mean on a shingle warranty?
During the non-prorated period the manufacturer covers a confirmed defect in full, and most brands include the labor to install replacement shingles. After it ends, coverage is prorated: the payout shrinks with the roof's age and usually covers materials only.
Is a lifetime shingle warranty really lifetime?
Only for the original owner of a single-family home, and only as a prorated warranty after the non-prorated period. Other building types get a fixed term, often 40 or 50 years, and a second owner often gets reduced coverage.
Can I transfer a shingle warranty when I sell my house?
Usually once, and often only within a window. TAMKO allows one transfer in the first 5 years; an IKO transferee gets the lesser of 10 years from installation or the remaining term; GAF's lifetime term carries to a second owner only if the transfer happens during the Smart Choice period.
Do I need a certified contractor for the best shingle warranty?
Yes, for every brand's top tier. GAF Golden Pledge needs a Master Elite contractor, Owens Corning Platinum Protection a Platinum Preferred contractor, CertainTeed 5-Star a SELECT ShingleMaster, and Malarkey, IKO and TAMKO limit their extended warranties to their certified programs.
What voids a roof shingle warranty?
Common causes are installation that does not follow the manufacturer's instructions, mixing in other brands' accessories when the warranty requires the manufacturer's own, not registering an enhanced warranty, missing the transfer deadline when you sell, and damage the warranty excludes, such as hail or wind above the rated speed.
Cost figures are planning estimates based on 2026 public data (Homewyse, Angi, Fixr, BLS). They are not contractor quotes. Full disclaimer · How we calculate.